Paul Brislen: Show us your tech policies
Paul Brislen: Show us your tech policies
When I was thinking about this column I thought I’d canvas the political parties views on tech and innovation, on all matters digital and on the ICT sector.
After all, ICT is the second largest export earner (sorry tourism), employs thousands of people, brings innovation and opportunity to the table, doesn’t require us to dig up national parks or drill for oil and is a highly paid, highly skilled, highly sought after sector.
Read More Year of the hacker: Why now, and why is NZ seen as a soft touch? Missing pieces – The state of contact-tracing in NZ Given the economic crisis facing the world as a result of Covid-19, any political party worth its salt should be focused on two short term issues: keeping citizens safe and keeping the economy alive (the implied longer-term goal of sorting out the environmental disaster that is unfolding around us is outside the remit of this column as it’s just too big for me to get my arms around at the moment).
Advertisement Advertise with NZME. And so it was I trotted off to the internet to review the parties’ policies and muse out loud about their plans for your enjoyment and edification.
Unfortunately, this is not that column. Not because I changed my mind or because something more important came up but because they don’t have any policies to scrutinise. They don’t have any plans to unpick. There is no strategy, there is no policy.
Labour’s policy page has 18 tiles (12 of which feature Jacinda Ardern which makes sense I suppose) relating to key policy areas. There’s Covid, naturally, transport, foreign policy, justice, housing and health among others.
There’s even one for the primary industry, which lays out quite a bit of detail about industry needs, spending and training. But there’s nothing about ICT.
Under Economy and Finance there’s nary a word, nor can we find it under Education and Training and while there’s a mention of it in Foreign Affairs and Trade (relating to the Christchurch Call and the “commitment by Governments and tech companies to eliminate terrorist and violent extremist content online”) it’s fleeting at best.
Green Party technology spokesperson Gareth Hughes. Photo / File New Zealand First doesn’t have one because it’s policy page points to the Coalition Agreement and suggests we “download the PDF” but the link doesn’t work. Neither National nor Act bother to mention the sector at all.
Related articles: WORLD Editorial: No end in sight to the war on reality 14 Sep, 2020 5:00am 4 minutes to read Only the Greens have an explicit ICT policy and while it’s full of the sorts of things you’d expect to see (the internet should be “free, open and unrestricted”, government should encourage the use of open software, we should close the digital divide) it’s light on details and lacking in any kind of initiatives or practical steps to introduce these lofty goals.
At this election the two MPs most publicly engaged with the tech sector – Clare Curran and Gareth Hughes – will both depart for new ventures leaving parliament largely unencumbered with MPs who understand the opportunities and potential of the tech sector for New Zealand as an economy, as a community and as a society.
Advertisement Advertise with NZME. Stuff the lot of them, I say.
Here are ten quick policy ideas that any political party is welcome to consider and they range from the easy to deploy to lofty goals.
1: Training and education
We should be encouraging kids to get into the tech sector and making it as easy as possible for them to do so. More teachers should be employed, more tertiary courses made available, and more funding given to building a generation of tech heads. There’s a world of demand for them out there and we will never be able to supply all its needs but we can certainly try. The upside is, tech is a well-paid sector and the ensuing wealth generated by all those Kiwi IT folk spending money in the local marketplace will help boost government coffers further.
We need fewer marketing people, fewer management types, fewer lawyers and accountants and more game developers, cybersecurity experts and programmers.
And while we’re at it, let’s make ‘critical thinking’ a standard curriculum item for kids at primary school all the way through, eh? The more we can teach them about who’s trying to tell them lies and rubbish the sooner they can start saying “hang on a minute” when their aunty shares madcap Facebook memes thinking they’re real.
2: Government as buyer of services
Advertisement Advertise with NZME. Government is our largest market for ICT product in New Zealand yet it doesn’t leverage that ability very well at all. Require government to buy locally made or explain why they aren’t and we boost the local economy, produce jobs for more Kiwis and who knows – the rest of the world might actually want to buy our kit off us as well.
And then there’s the duplication. Let’s buy sensibly, eh government? Does each and every school, hospital, government department and local council really need a bespoke client management solution? Reader: it does not.
3: Research and development
New Zealand’s R&D spend remains woeful – less than half the OECD average. That shortfall comes primarily from the investment sector – the public spend is on par with other countries, but we simply don’t encourage investment in the tech sector here. Government can pull on the taxation lever all it likes but the real problem is a lack of understanding or awareness among local money lenders. We need to address that head on – government doesn’t need to spend more but it does need to encourage and enable investors to come here and set up shop. That should be a priority.
4: Privacy and Consumer Data Rights
We need to encourage more people to be more comfortable using services online and while COVID has done a good job of turning us all into online shoppers, we need to extend that out to include government services and all manner of other interactions as well.
Advertisement Advertise with NZME. That means training but it also means upweighting the Privacy Act and enshrining New Zealanders’ rights to their own data in a new Consumer Data Rights act. Give it some teeth and make sure we have informed consent before we move data around the place or copy a user’s entire web history or Facebook account, for instance.
We need a much stronger stance on this. Currently we have the GCSB and its National Cyber Security Centre and MBIE has CERT NZ which will help raise the public’s awareness of issues but we need so much more. This will be a huge battleground in the next decade and probably longer – we aren’t ready and we need to be to ensure we don’t have foreign actors sowing the seeks of chaos while our backs are turned. More money, more funding, more awareness, more training, more support.
6: Economic opportunity
Seize the day, New Zealand! Let’s get out there and champion our ICT sector in international trade. Where is our Fielddays equivalent for the tech sector? Why isn’t ICT our first discussion when we’re selling our wares offshore? Why do we have the Productivity Commission writing reports that say we can never build stuff locally so we shouldn’t even bother?
7: Regional economic opportunity
Advertisement Advertise with NZME. While we’re at it, let’s help decentralise our ICT companies. Let’s pay them to move out to the Hawke’s Bay or Northland, or Nelson. Let’s encourage new high tech entrepreneurs into New Zealand but incentivise them to set up shop outside the main centres. We have the UFB out to 75% of the population – let’s push on and get the rest of the country connected. Let’s build those billion dollar businesses from the bach.
8: New Zealand digital taonga
It is critically important that New Zealand retains ownership of its own history and its own culture. To do that we have to make sure New Zealand data is treated by New Zealand laws, that local content is produced and curated and stored and shared locally. There is so much to do on this topic alone we should have started a decade ago but let’s get on with it now.
9: The robots are coming
The robots aren’t just coming for our jobs, they’re here, so what are we going to do about it? I look forward to my GP telling me she’s pretty sure that lump is nothing to worry about but she’s run the biopsy through the AI which agrees. The robots won’t sit in our seats but they’ll replace the middlemen in so many industries and it won’t by driving buses or flying planes (although it will eventually) but it’ll be the AI that assists the doctor, the legal software that works cheaply and delivers better wills and contracts, the chatbot that eventually gets it right for customer service. We need a plan for how we’re going to retrain all those people who would otherwise be employed by jobs the robots can do. And then we need a plan for the rest of us.
10: A tech czar
Advertisement Advertise with NZME. What about bitcoin and blockchain? What about AI and machine learning? What about AR/VR? What’s the next big thing? Government doesn’t know and it’s terrified of being taken for a ride by the next snake oil salesman singing a jaunty song about monorails. We actually do need practical hands-on advice for government about what’s real, what’s plausible, what’s possible and what’s total rot. We actually do need a government CIO who has some weight to be able to oversee spending and deployments and to rein in the excesses of the industry.
There you go – that’s ten policies in ten minutes. I’m sure there are others that make a lot more sense – let me know what you’d like to see on the agenda for the next policy session of your preferred party. And if you’re not registered, do sign up so you can vote. You may not get the sticker this year because of Covid but you certainly will contribute to a better New Zealand.
Paul Brislen is an Auckland-based technology commentator. He posts at at ITP Techblog .